Transforming Debate for Inclusive and Impactful Participation Objective: To empower thousands—or even millions—to contribute meaningfully to debates by leveraging structured organization and robust evaluation criteria. Together, we can ensure every voice is heard and every idea is thoughtfully considered.
Oct 4, 2006
My Dad recovered from a scary surgery
On the 4th of July, 2006, my dad, Marvin, was getting out of his RV. We were at my cousin's cabin in McCall Idaho. He twisted his ankle, getting out, and hit his head.
We were more concerned about his ankle, but should have been worried about his head, because he actually was knocked unconscious... we don't know how long he was out in the forest laying there, and I don't like the vision of him hobbling to the cabin…
Anyways he must have hurt his head. A few months later he started having cognitive problems. He was falling down mowing the lawn… he had just had eye surgery, and at first he thought he was having problems with his vision…he went to the emergency room when one morning he couldn't get out of bed…
My mom was really scared. Everyone. I think he went in on a Friday. The doctor was out, and so he had to wait till Monday to have the operation: a bi-lateral hemotosis, or something… basically it was to stop the bleeding… the blood was pooling up in his brain…
He had to go through therapy to learn to walk, and do everything again…
They had him doing mind exercises…
That was more than 6 years ago. From that time he has seen 2 more of my kids born, seen them at Christmas and for summer break, visited them here, and spoken to them almost every weekend.
I'm very grateful for modern medicine, and for my dad.
Sep 16, 2006
You should track family graduation photos on the same page
I was still very young when my brother graduated from High School |
Driving to high school graduation |
Yeah |
1998 Megan's BA in English. I finished Ricks the same time (?) she finished at the Y. Best girlfriend ever. |
Best mom. Ever. |
Best dad. Ever. |
1998, Assoc Mech Engr, Victor Forsnes. Probably the best teacher I ever had. |
My parents took this picture after I graduated from Ricks in 1998 |
2002, BS Electrical Engineering |
J, 1st Grade |
Visiting Washington, Oregon, and Northern California state parks can be a good vacation
We brought our tent, stayed in State Parks, and only got rained out once.
- went to Mt. Saint Helens. Did not pay for helicopter tour,
- went swimming in the Columbia river,
- rented a 2 person boat,
- lake canoed
- took a ferry to Victoria on British Columbia,
- walked in the red-woods,
- visited KC
- stayed in a Casino in Reno
- Spent a day in San Fransico
- saw the worlds shortest river
- walked down to crater lake
- made Megan cry driving down the world's curviest road
Driving through a tree |
Megan making hash-browns on our Camp Stove. This looks like the coast |
One of the many places that waves ambushed us |
At a Japanese garden in Seattle. We were able to visit KC |
Megan and I had fun on our Senior prom
REM blasted in our mind, a little too loud for music to be when you are trying to discuss matters of importance. Still, we were proud of our flippant attitude in determining the most extravagant event as graduating seniors.
Given our dire circumstances, I said, "Don't worry about it. We'll just figure it out tomorrow morning." The topic of conversation was what we would do tomorrow morning. It was too late for sensible people to try and be sensible.
Derek had a hole in his pants, and he proceeded to rip off the bottom portion of his lower garment. Koji heard the ripping noise and looked at Derek with that expression only Koji could make (Koji was a foreign exchange student. He was a member of a punk rock band in Japan but was harmless in a way that very few Americans could possibly imagine. He also personified the bad-singing Japanese person to a tea and attempted everything from Led Zeplin to the Beatles (at a moment's notice). The look shows his complete inability to understand American members of the human race. My Mom looked like she disagreed with my conclusion of normality when she rolled her eyes in our general direction as she put away the groceries.
I've never known my mom to go shopping at 11 o'clock. She must have been bored to have wandered about the deserted grocery store to look for food to fill my lonely stomach.
Derek and I concluded that we needed to go to some park down by the River. Our plans involved:
- Looking at pictographs and running around and flailing our arms about, and just being downright silly.
- Doing some target practice with my Dad's Guns.
That night, I tossed and turned like a hairy-toothed madman, pulling and stretching a quilt trying to cover his cold feet. I was ill. I had a nice cold-sore developing, and my nose was runny. Derek called at 7:00 AM to inform me to get ready to make a purchasing arrangement for groceries and flowers. I rose from bed at 8:00, too tired to flail my arms about. Derek arrived at my abode at 8:30 and waited while I brushed my teeth. We then got groceries, flowers, and girls.
Megan and I drove around Derek's house until he got there. We fixed and consumed breakfast, which consisted of Swedish pancakes (a little heavy on the egg, but delicious), fruit with cream, and OJ (of the fruit variety.)
Katie, Derek's youngest sibling, ate with us. I wanted to hit her. Derek did. Just joking, she was fine, and as a result of her fineness, no violence ensued.
After breakfast, we walked around the Snake River, looked at pictographs, threw rocks off the bridge, and messed around. I didn't feel silly enough to flail my arms about. We stopped at a shooting range, shot beer bottles and clay pigeons, and listened to Pachel Bell. Some guy told us not to use my handgun, not to shoot beer bottles, and to pick up the garbage, all of which we were obliged to do, and all of which we did. We had a nice drive, and I think everyone enjoyed themselves. We then went our separate ways to prepare for the big event.
Derek picked me up at 6:00 in his Lexi, and we picked up Megan at about 6:10. She looked very virtuous, lovely, of good report, and praiseworthy. We went to Lara's house, where the congregations and multiple hosts of people were gathered to look at us, say absolutely nothing intelligent, and take our pictures, all at the same time. We stepped inside the living room with more people than square feet and more cameras than the Grand Canyon on a Japanese holiday. We muddled through our trials and woe and got on our way.
We had our pictures taken three times. Once I got home after the night, I tried the smiles I used in front of a mirror, and they looked exactly like what they were: fake. Not that I wasn't having a good time, just that I had no reason to smile looking at some annoying woman telling me how to hold Megan's hand.
Having completed our mission, we proceeded onward and upward to The Gamekeeper! The salmon was interesting kind of enjoyable, but not succulent or ultimately satisfying. It's not something I totally chewed down on. Although I guess I did, kind of, chow down. Not because it was extraordinarily good, just cause I'm ordinarily a pig, and I forgot to eat differently than usual. I was worried about talking, so I ate pretty fast.
After dinner, we went to the dance. It was loud. I wanted to go do something fun. I knew they had a baby grand piano on the stage at the Civic Center, and I thought it would be cool to play piano or something. I wanted to do something memorable instead of just going in and trying to talk over the noise.
I wanted Megan to feel comfortable, but it was unsupervised, and I didn't think she wanted to go in. It was probably locked anyway, but for a while, I thought I was with Derek, so I thought we could find a way. Then I remembered I was with Megan, so after being immature and trying to do something fun, I succumbed to the dance, and we went in and sat down at a table. We wandered around a little, talking to some of our different friends. We danced about 5 slow dances. I wish we would have danced to Stairway to Heaven, but maybe Megan wouldn't have liked it.
Surprisingly, they played Offspring and some other non-traditional dance music. After prom, we went to Video City to get a movie, but it was closed being 12:01. We just got "The River Wild" from Lara's residence and watched the movie at Derek's. In conclusion, it was a fabulous, fun-filled night for everyone. Or at least, I hope.
Later, I learned that Megan was very upset that we did not get dessert. Derek got some flaming thing.
Me checking Megan out. Jesus watching. |
Life is filled with funny events and timing
Reasons to Agree:
- Coincidence in Timing (A1): Megan's performance of "A Marshmallow World" in a minor key aligns humorously with her dating frustrations, symbolizing life's quirky timing.
- Linkage Score: High (if the argument is that life's coincidences often reflect our personal experiences humorously).
- Evidence: Personal anecdote, psychological theories of perception and confirmation bias.
- Prom Date Plan Discussion (A2): The conversation with Megan's father about prom timings humorously highlights parental concerns and the unpredictability of plans.
- Linkage Score: Moderate (if the argument focuses on the humor arising from generational differences and expectations).
- Evidence: Personal experience, social norms about dating and parental roles.
- Coincidence in Timing (A1): Megan's performance of "A Marshmallow World" in a minor key aligns humorously with her dating frustrations, symbolizing life's quirky timing.
Reasons to Disagree:
- Confirmation Bias (D1): People tend to remember and give significance to coincidences while ignoring routine events, leading to a skewed perception of their frequency.
- Linkage Score: High (argues directly against the idea that life is exceptionally filled with funny coincidences).
- Evidence: Psychological studies on confirmation bias and memory.
- Confirmation Bias (D1): People tend to remember and give significance to coincidences while ignoring routine events, leading to a skewed perception of their frequency.
Conclusion Scoring:
- Cumulative Argument Score: Total scores of A1 and A2 minus D1, adjusted by their respective linkage scores.
- Impact of Conclusion: The belief's score could affect our perception of life's events, influencing our outlook and mood.
Associated Beliefs:
- Simulation Theory: Some funny coincidences may lead to a belief in simulation theory.
- Linkage to Main Belief: Moderate (humorous coincidences can be used as anecdotal evidence for larger metaphysical theories).
- Evidence to Explore: Philosophical arguments for and against simulation theory, empirical data supporting or refuting common coincidences.
Analytical Insights:
- Humor in Everyday Life: The belief underlines the role of humor in interpreting life events.
- Psychological Impact: Such beliefs can influence mental health by framing life experiences in a lighter, more humorous manner.
Moving across the country can be hard
Our fist day we go snowed in at the mountain-pass going into Salt Lake, and we had to stay the night in Burley, Idaho after only traveling a few hours.
In that hotel I realized that I had my mother-in-law's keys. We had to mail them to her the next day.
We fought icy patches, blowing snow, and light snow flurries all the way across country. All our: shampoo, olive oil, and bath-tub-bubble-bath froze across the plains, as we experienced negative 20 and 30 degree weather.
Finley (our dog) seemed depressed on the trip (even thought he got more space than Megan or I), and slept all most the whole way there. Each morning we would have to break the ice out of his doggy bowl.
We arrived in Chicago on their coldest day in 4 years. There was a 100 yard walkway between our apartment, up the stairs, and to the U-Haul.
It wasn't fun, but we were alive, and finally together again.
Sep 15, 2006
My parents are cool to visit me in Illinois
There's something truly special about a visit from your parents. It's a gesture that speaks volumes about familial bonds, love, and commitment, and I've been lucky to experience this multiple times. Despite the long, 22-hour drive from their home to mine in Illinois, my parents have made the journey not once, but four times. They've driven here twice, flown twice, and even brought their trailer on one occasion.
Sure, my home might not be the Ritz Carlton, and they've had to make do with our pull-out couch, but these small inconveniences never dampen the spirit of their visits. We always cherish their company, the shared laughs, stories, and the joy they bring, especially to their grandkids.
One visit that stands out is from September 2010 when both Mom and Dad came out after Philip, my son, was born. Their excitement and eagerness to meet their new grandchild turned their journey into a grand adventure. We spent a lovely day at the Chicago Arboretum, creating memories that we still fondly look back on.
September 2010 at the Chicago arboretum, when Both Mom and Dad came out after Philip was born.
2010 when my Mom came out by herself when Megan was on bed rest.
2009 Visit
Related Links:
Summer Vacation to visit the family can be hard but are important
Assertion #1: Summer Vacation to visit the
family can be hard...
Reasons to agree:
1.
It is hard to travel
with kids that are younger than 2.
1.
Young kids
have separation anxiety.
2.
Young kids may have
problems sleeping in new places.
2.
Kids have a hard time
getting out of and into routines.
3.
Traveling is hard
1.
Traffic can be annoying
2.
Being in a car for a
long time is hard, especially for kids. It hurts my lower back.
4.
Our kids always get sick
on vacation.
1.
2012
1.
J through up on
a mattress, and in bed two days before we left.
2.
P through up in bed.
3.
My wife was sick, and we
got a late start.
4.
I didn't get sick until
Idaho, luckily.
5.
2-year-olds cry all the
time.
1. National Lampoons Vacation
Assertion #2: ... it is important to visit family.
Reasons to agree:
1.
It is good to try to
spend time with their grandparents. Kids need as many positive relationships
with safe adults as possible. Grandparents usually have love, interest, and
motivation to help their children. Spending time with grandparents helps answer
the question of "where did I come from", and "who am
I".
2.
Going on a family
vacation can be disorienting because you get out of a routine
but some times it is important to get out of a routine and look at your
life differently.
3.
When kids see
their cousins they can see that people live lives
2012
I'm writing this from my parent's place. As our family has grown in size, the
economics of flying with more people has suffered. And so our 2012 Summer
Vacation (AKA: Trips to see family in Idaho) started off with a 1,700-mile
drive with 3 kids in a car.
Below is our adventure-packed "travel laug."
Day 1, Drove to Nebraska
We planned to leave on Friday and drive for 11 hours. However, on Wednesday (or
Thursday?) P threw up in our Bed, and J threw up on his mattress (which got
thrown away). Wife wasn't feeling good and so we didn't leave till 2:30pm. We
ended up driving 470 miles (8 hours) and making it to Omaha Nebraska. It turns
out they had the Olympic swimming qualifications in Omaha, and some college
sports, so most all of the hotels were taken. The Days-In hotel was very musty.
I didn't get to sleep until after 2pm...
Day 2, Drove to Utah
We arrived in Salt Lake at 1:30am, after waiting for 2 hours in Nebraska when
the Highway Patrol shut down the freeway, while they life-flighted some people
away from a 6 car pile up. There were very bad winds, very hard rains. Because
of all the lightning strikes, the power was out at one of the gas stations we
stopped at. Garmin told us to drive up a dirt road, but we ignored it and got
stuck in traffic for 2 hours.
2-hour traffic jam in Nebraska
Day 3, Drove to Nampa Idaho
We slept in @ Uncle L' house. Visited Wife's Uncle and brother, on the way to
Idaho.
Day 4, Sick
I was sick and slept most of the day.
Went to fireworks @ Granny Janie's.
J stayed the night at Amy's house
Day 5, Drove to McCall Idaho
Packed up again, and headed to McCall.
Stopped at the Cascade Water Park to watch the kayakers surfing.
Day 6, In the woods and on a lake of Northern Idaho
My daughter and youngest son saw deer on a hike with Grandma and Grandpa.
Went on a hike with my brother.
Went with my brother and their family to see the McCall fire works.
Spent time on the beach
Day 7, Still in the woods
My brother and the cousins left. Read. J was bored.
Day 8, Woods
Wife cleaned on the atomic scale. Ate at My Father's Place in McCall. Went to
Ponderosa State Park. Saw a deer. Returned home.
Day 9, Drove to Nampa (again), time with Family Watched Men In
Black 3 with my brother (thanks Amy for watching the kids).
Day10, Family Church.
Anita Kay, Greg, and Steve's family came over. It's great that the kids got to
play with their cousins.
Day11, Family Wife's mom fixed breakfast.
Used quickcrete to fill in a sinkhole in Granny Janny's yard, moved some rock,
got stung by a wasp.
A quick wind storm knocked over Dad's crooked willow. We borrowed Bob Barton's
chain saw to cut it up. It was probably about 1-1/2 feet across. Got stung by a
2nd wasp.
Visited with Wife Aunt and Cousin from Texas.
Day12, Dad took the tree to the dump. Only cost $4.
J wanted to fly a kite, but there was no wind. Grandma said we should fly the
kite behind grandpa's ATV. It worked great. J wanted to fly the kite on the way
home, but it got stuck in a tree.
Day13
Day 14
We went to Wife's uncle, Richard Chadwick's funeral. He sounds like a
great guy, father, and husband. I only met him a few times. Wife and I watched
his kids one time at their home in Meridian, when all the kids were little.
Dinner with Wife, my Brother, and his wife.
Softball with his church softball team.
Day 15 Went to the Zoo Boise, which was not too bad coming from
Chicago. It was a great day outside (the day before had been in the hundreds).
Went to the Morrison Knudsen Nature Center. Saw a whole bunch
of stuffed animals, a living deer in the parking lot, sturgeon in the pond,
small and large rainbow trout, and some sort of crane or egret.
ATV w/ J and A.
Day 16 Grandma and grandpa went to a grandaughter's singing
performance
Wife took the kids to visit a cousin
I got packed, and updated this
Day 17
Flew back home
2011
Steve and CoraLyn watched Pip while we took J and Ason to Yellowstone.
Steve was going to Jump Creek and took J and I with him.
Its cool taking J to some of the places that you went to when you were little.
July 2006. A 5 months old
Christmas 2004 soon after J was born (2 months old)
Aug 22, 2006
Education Reform
Education Reform
My whole life I have been frustrated when things are not they way that I think they should be. I started a life long habit of sharing my political beliefs with a letter to the school cooks that included less than profound poetry on the quality of food served to us in the cafeteria. The letter got me kicked out of the lunch line for 1 week. A letter to my teacher on the effectiveness of her method started a back and forth corresponded into different teaching philosophy that lead me to Ivan Illich and his book De-schooling Society. This experience in 9th grade with a thick skinned English teacher lead me to a work on the details of how my school would work better whenever I became annoyed with something a teacher did brainstorm with myself new ways of addressing the problems.
I had plans of going into schooling, but in the back of my mind I could hear my uncle saying, how can you teach others how to make it in the world, until you have?
Possible Ideas for Schools
Bill or Rights
- No student has to do anything for a grade, that does not further his education.
- Students, if treated incorrectly have a right to trial by peers.
Schools and Business
- Schools should embrace Businesses as partners.
- Schools must embrace the virtues of a competitive market place. Much of the world's knowledge is locked up in Businesses. Businesses have a lot to offer schools, and schools have a lot to offer businesses. Businesses would benefit by cooperating with schools by having bragging rights, advertisement rights, recruiting rights.
- Kids need to know that they are going to have to fit into a business atmosphere. Business leaders could give students encouragement to gain a better education.
- Teachers must be familiar with the business world.
- Schools should let business people from the community teach classes, weather they have a teacher's certificate or not.
- Set up an exchange system with businesses where teachers go to work for businesses some times, and business people come in and teach
- We should let businesses advertise on anything that they donate. We are not communists. For instance
Libraries
Ideas:
- Schools should have a place where people can just study a subject. Provide a test and let them get credit for a class.
- Let students stay in library to study after school. Announce. Ask teachers to be all together to, if they have to stay after school. Provide music. Teachers can grade papers, detintion. Let them use computers. Let star-bucks go on the schools, were people hang out and talk.
Test:
Ideas:
- Have a section of info they will have to know. Easy things that everyhone has got to understand. Could tell them befor hand what they would have to know
Teachers
- Teachers can all stay together in their own corner, or they can stay so kids can talk to them. They can bring music, food, ext.
May 28, 2006
A New Open-Source Politics
Just as Linux lets users design their own operating systems, so 'netroots' politicos may redesign our nominating system.
MSNBC.com |
A New Open-Source Politics
Just as Linux lets users design their own operating systems, so 'netroots' politicos may redesign our nominating system.
June 5, 2006 issue - Bob Schieffer of CBS News made a good point on "The Charlie Rose Show" last week. He said that successful presidents have all skillfully exploited the dominant medium of their times. The Founders were eloquent writers in the age of pamphleteering. Franklin D. Roosevelt restored hope in 1933 by mastering radio. And John F. Kennedy was the first president elected because of his understanding of television.
Will 2008 bring the first Internet president? Last time, Howard Dean and later John Kerry showed that the whole idea of "early money" is now obsolete in presidential politics. The Internet lets candidates who catch fire raise millions in small donations practically overnight. That's why all the talk of Hillary Clinton's "war chest" making her the front runner for 2008 is the most hackneyed punditry around. Money from wealthy donors remains the essential ingredient in most state and local campaigns, but "free media" shapes the outcome of presidential races, and the Internet is the freest media of all.
No one knows exactly where technology is taking politics, but we're beginning to see some clues. For starters, the longtime stranglehold of media consultants may be over. In 2004, Errol Morris, the director of "The Thin Blue Line" and "The Fog of War," on his own initiative made several brilliant anti-Bush ads (they featured lifelong Republicans explaining why they were voting for Kerry). Not only did Kerry not air the ads, he told me recently he never even knew they existed. In 2008, any presidential candidate with half a brain will let a thousand ad ideas bloom (or stream) online and televise only those that are popular downloads. Deferring to "the wisdom of crowds" will be cheaper and more effective.
Open-source politics has its hazards, starting with the fact that most people over 35 will need some help with the concept. But just as Linux lets tech-savvy users avoid Microsoft and design their own operating systems, so "netroots" political organizers may succeed in redesigning our current nominating system. But there probably won't be much that's organized about it. By definition, the Internet strips big shots of their control of the process, which is a good thing. Politics is at its most invigorating when it's cacophonous and chaotic.
To begin busting up the dumb system we have for selecting presidents, a bipartisan group will open shop this week at Unity08.com. This Internet-based third party is spearheaded by three veterans of the antique 1976 campaign: Democrats Hamilton Jordan and Gerald Rafshoon helped get Jimmy Carter elected; Republican Doug Bailey did media for Gerald Ford before launching the political TIP SHEET Hotline. They are joined by the independent former governor of Maine, Angus King, and a collection of idealistic young people who are also tired of a nominating process that pulls the major party candidates to the extremes. Their hope: to get even a fraction of the 50 million who voted for the next American Idol to nominate a third-party candidate for president online and use this new army to get him or her on the ballot in all 50 states. The idea is to go viral—or die. "The worst thing that could happen would be for a bunch of old white guys like us to run this," Jordan says.
The Unity08 plan is for an online third-party convention in mid-2008, following the early primaries. Any registered voter could be a delegate; their identities would be confirmed by cross-referencing with voter registration rolls (which would also prevent people from casting more than one ballot). That would likely include a much larger number than the few thousand primary voters who all but nominate the major party candidates in Iowa and New Hampshire. This virtual process will vote on a centrist platform and nominate a bipartisan ticket. The idea is that even if the third-party nominee didn't win, he would wield serious power in the '08 election, which will likely be close.
There are plenty of ways for this process to prove meaningless, starting with the major parties deciding to nominate independent-minded candidates like John McCain (OK, the old McCain) or Mark Warner. Third-party efforts have usually been candidate-driven, and the centrist names tossed around by way of example (Chuck Hagel, Sam Nunn, Tom Kean) don't have much marquee value in the blogosphere. And the organizers would have to design safeguards to keep the whole thing from being hijacked.
But funny things happen in election years. With an issue as eye-glazing as the deficit, a wacky, jug-eared Texan named Ross Perot received 19 percent of the vote in 1992 and 7 percent in 1996. He did it with "Larry King Live" and an 800 number. In a country where more than 40 percent of voters now self-identify as independents, it's no longer a question of whether the Internet will revolutionize American politics, but when.
For more, go to JonathanAlter.com
© 2006 MSNBC.com