Nov 8, 2012

Should Marco Rubio Be Our Next President? An Examination

Pros of a Rubio Presidency

  1. Economic Stewardship: Critics argue that Democrats haven't efficiently balanced the deficit. Rubio has proposed fiscal policies aimed at reducing government expenditure, potentially reducing the deficit.

  2. Incentives for Success: Some believe that Rubio's policies favor the successful and discourage wasteful spending, promoting economic growth.

  3. Diversification of the Presidency: Having the first Hispanic Republican president could disrupt patterns of racial party alliance and stimulate balanced representation across parties.

  4. Family Values: Rubio, a father of four, could bring a family-oriented perspective to his presidency.

Cons of a Rubio Presidency

  1. Lack of Executive Experience: Rubio served as a Senator, but critics argue that gubernatorial experience could better prepare a candidate for the presidency.

  2. Leadership Questions: Some critics question whether Rubio has demonstrated leadership on major issues.

Further Exploration

For more in-depth discussion and exploration of political and social issues, visit our main sites: Group Intel and Idea Stock Exchange.

# of reasons to agree: +14
# of reasons to disagree: -2
# of reasons to agree with reasons to agree: +3
# of reasons to agree with reasons to disagree: -0
Total Idea Score: +15

Don't like the score? It is easy to change the score. Just post a reason to agree or disagree with the overall idea, or any of the reasons and the score will change.

===============================================================
Images

  1. Leave a comment with a link to a photo, and I'll add it. 
===============================================================
===============================================================
Videos

  1. Leave a comment so I can add a reason.
===============================================================
Interest
  1. Judicial Balance: Supporters may desire a more balanced judiciary. They believe that after periods of liberal influence, a shift towards a conservative viewpoint is needed to maintain equilibrium.
  2. Fiscal Responsibility: Supporters are concerned about the national debt and its potential impacts on future generations. They trust in Rubio's proposed fiscal policies to tackle this issue effectively.
  3. Strong Bipartisanship: Supporters value a robust two-party system, arguing that political diversity is key to a healthy democracy. They see Rubio's potential candidacy as contributing to this dynamic.
  4. Diversity in Leadership: Supporters believe that leadership should reflect the nation's diversity. They see potential in candidates like Rubio to represent various communities within the country.
  5. Nominee Considerations: Some supporters might be deliberating over potential Republican nominees, based on their policy platforms and potential to draw a diverse electorate. They may be comparing Rubio's suitability with other potential candidates in the current political context.


  1. Economic Stability: Supporters and critics alike share a common interest in avoiding hyperinflation. They agree on the need for economic policies that promote stability and growth.

  2. Preparedness: Everyone desires a government that is well-prepared to handle national and international challenges. This includes everything from economic crises to public health emergencies.

  1. Fiscal Awareness: Critics might argue for a more detailed understanding of the nation's fiscal situation. They might feel that current policies are steering the country towards a "fiscal cliff" of unsustainable debt.

  2. Problem Recognition: Critics might also desire a more straightforward acknowledgment of the nation's problems, rather than denying or downplaying them. They may believe in confronting these issues head-on, with comprehensive plans and proactive policies.

===============================================================
Podcast
Podcast that agree: +
  1. http://www.learnoutloud.com/Podcast-Directory/Politics/Conservative-Politics
Podcast that disagree: -
  1. http://www.learnoutloud.com/Podcast-Directory/Politics/Liberal-Politics
===============================================================
Experts
Unbiased Experts who agree: +
  1. Paul Ryan, Former Speaker of the House and economic policy expert.
  2. Condoleezza Rice, Former Secretary of State and political scientist.
Unbiased Experts who disagree: -
  1. Elizabeth Warren, U.S. Senator and expert on bankruptcy law.
  2. Paul Krugman, Nobel laureate economist.
===============================================================
Books
Books that agree: +
  1. "The Way Forward: Renewing the American Idea" by Paul Ryan.
  2. "American Dreams: Restoring Economic Opportunity for Everyone" by Marco Rubio.
Books that  disagree: -
  1. "Our Time Is Now: Power, Purpose, and the Fight for a Fair America" by Stacey Abrams.
  2. "The Fight for Fifteen: The Right Wage for a Working America" by David Rolf.
===============================================================
Miscellaneous
Related arguments:

Websites That Might Agree:

  1. The National Review
  2. The American Conservative
  3. The Daily Wire
  4. The Federalist
  5. Republican National Committee

Websites That Might Disagree:

  1. The Democratic National Committee
  2. Mother Jones
  3. HuffPost Politics
  4. The Intercept
  5. ThinkProgress

a) Fundamental beliefs or principles one must reject to also reject this belief:

Pro: To support Marco Rubio as president, you may have to reject beliefs in:

  1. Progressive economic policies.
  2. Universal healthcare as a right.
  3. Green New Deal or equivalent radical environmental measures.

Con: To reject Rubio as president, you may have to reject beliefs in:

  1. Conservative economic policies.
  2. Limited government intervention.
  3. Traditional Republican stances on social issues.

b) Alternate expressions of this belief:

Pro: #Rubio2024, #MarcoForPresident, #RubioRevolution

Con: #NotMyCandidate, #AnyoneButRubio, #NoToRubio

c) Criteria to demonstrate the strength or weakness of this belief:

  1. Policy positions and track record: Does Rubio’s stance align with your beliefs?
  2. Leadership ability: Can Rubio effectively lead and make tough decisions?
  3. Popular opinion: What do polls say about Rubio's chances?

d) Shared interests or values with potential dissenters:

  1. Economic prosperity.
  2. National security.
  3. Quality education for all.

e) Key differences or obstacles:

  1. Economic Policy: Progressive versus conservative.
  2. Social Issues: Liberal versus traditional.
  3. Foreign Policy: Interventionist versus non-interventionist.

f) Strategies for dialogue:

  1. Hosting town halls for open discussions.
  2. Encouraging respectful debate on social media.
  3. Promoting evidence-based discussions over ideological beliefs.

g) Key resources to understand this topic:

  1. Marco Rubio's Senate voting record.
  2. Rubio's book "American Dreams: Restoring Economic Opportunity for Everyone."
  3. Analysis of Rubio's policy proposals by independent think tanks.
  4. Public opinion polls on Rubio's candidacy.

To further delve into pro/con analysis and collective intelligence, visit my platforms: Group Intel and Idea Stock Exchange.