Belief: The US Federal Government is Too Big

-

Reasons to Agree:

  1. The Federal Government Should Be as Small as Possible – A smaller government reduces bureaucracy, limits overreach, and encourages efficiency.

    • Reduced Bureaucracy: Less government involvement streamlines processes and reduces red tape.

    • Limited Overreach: A smaller federal government is less likely to intrude on individual liberties and state autonomy.

    • Increased Efficiency: Reduced scope can lead to more focused and efficient government operations.

    • Lower Taxes: Potentially lower taxes due to reduced government spending.

    • Economic Growth: Less regulation and lower taxes can stimulate economic growth.

  2. The Federal Government Should Return Power to the States and the People – Decentralization allows states to create policies more tailored to their unique populations and needs.

    • Tailored Policies: States can create policies more specifically suited to their diverse populations and local needs.

    • Increased Responsiveness: State and local governments may be more responsive to their citizens.

    • Policy Innovation: States can experiment with different policies that could be adopted nationally if successful.

    • Reduced Federal Control: Shifting power away from the federal government empowers states and communities to make their own decisions.

Reasons to Disagree:

  1. The Federal Government Plays a Necessary Role in Addressing National Issues:

    • National Standards: The federal government ensures nationwide protections for civil rights, workplace safety, and environmental regulations.

    • Interstate Issues: Many issues like climate change, national security, and interstate commerce require federal coordination.

    • Economic Stability: The federal government plays a role in managing the national economy, stabilizing markets, and implementing fiscal policies.

    • Social Safety Nets: Federal programs like Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid protect vulnerable populations.

    • Infrastructure and Research: Large-scale infrastructure projects and scientific research benefit from federal funding and coordination.

  2. A Larger Federal Government Can Be More Effective and Equitable:

    • Economies of Scale: Government functions like defense and Social Security can be more efficiently managed at a federal level.

    • Redistribution and Equity: The federal government can address economic inequality across states.

    • Preventing a "Race to the Bottom": Without federal oversight, states may lower regulations to attract businesses, harming citizens.

    • Protecting Minority Rights: The federal government plays a crucial role in ensuring equal treatment under the law.

Score:

  • # of reasons to agree: +2

  • # of reasons to disagree: -2

  • # of reasons to agree with reasons to agree: +0

  • # of reasons to agree with reasons to disagree: +0

  • Total Idea Score: 0

Don't like the score? It is easy to change the score. Just post a reason to agree or disagree with the overall idea, or any of the reasons, and the score will change.

Images

Images That Agree: +

  1. Link to image

Images That Disagree: -

  1. Leave a comment with a link to a photo, and I'll add it.

Websites

Websites That Agree: +

  1. National Review

  2. Town Hall

  3. Newsmax

  4. GOP

  5. NRCC

  6. Texas GOP

Websites That Disagree: -

  1. Democratic National Committee

Videos

Videos That Agree: +

  1. Milton Friedman - Why Government Is the Problem - Free To Choose Network

  2. The Danger of Big Government - PragerU

Videos That Disagree: -

  1. The Case for Big Government - The Young Turks

  2. Why We Need Big Government - Second Thought

Books

Books That Agree: +

  • After America: Get Ready for Armageddon by Mark Steyn

  • Ameritopia: The Unmaking of America by Mark R. Levin

  • Mugged: Racial Demagoguery from the Seventies to Obama by Ann Coulter

  • The Road to Serfdom by F.A. Hayek

  • Basic Economics by Thomas Sowell

Books That Disagree: -

  • The Spirit Level: Why More Equal Societies Almost Always Do Better by Richard G. Wilkinson and Kate Pickett

  • Capital in the Twenty-First Century by Thomas Piketty

Interest / Motivation

Valid Interest of Those Who Agree: +

  1. Efficiency

  2. Individual Liberty

  3. Limited Government

  4. Fiscal Responsibility

  5. Free Markets

Valid Interest of Those Who Disagree: -

  1. Government Safety Nets

  2. Social Justice and Equality

  3. Public Services

  4. Regulation and Oversight

  5. Collective Action

Common Valid Interest:

  1. American Strength

Opposing Valid Interest:

  1. Fiscal Responsibility vs. Social Needs

  2. Individualism vs. Collectivism

  3. Trust in Government

Miscellaneous

Related Arguments:

  • Federalism and States' Rights

  • Economic Regulation vs. Free Markets

  • The Role of Government in History

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

You should write the Life History of your Grandmothers Gwendolyn Higbee Matheson (Mom's Mom)

-
Image
This is my mom's mom's life history. Also check out the ongoing projects for my   dad ,  mom , and   and  dad's mom .  Typed by Michael Laub, from a photocopy of the original that Gwendolyn typed on a typewriter. Comments by me in parenthesis Henry Gordon, Gwendolyn Higbee, And LaVane Matheson   It must have been a sad day when I was born. I was the fifth child in less than nine years, and arthritis had made mother ( Sarah Ann Jones ) a cripple long before that December 5, 1891. She was bed-fast most of the time until she died early in 1895 (10th of March) when I was a little over 3 yrs. old. Five little children had to be parceled out with relatives, and it fell to my lot to live with Grandmother Higbee. So you see I went to live in a large home that had already housed many children and where no more were to come. (click below to read more)
Read more

You should write your father's Life History

-
Image
Best reasons to agree : +6 Its hard to understand yourself very well without trying to figure out parents. Your kids will want to know about their grandparents. If your kids become famous, biographers will want to know about your family.  Writing about your parents can be a fun activity that brings your family together. Its a good way to remember stuff.  A well rounded person can have fun, work hard, relax, and also find time to write about their experiences, or document what they are doing, or did.  You can't just do stuff all the time... you also have to reflect... going through the process of gathering stories, photos, and memories allows you to process, and look back... Best reasons to disagree : -1  Every time you spend doing one thing is time you can't spend doing something else.  Score: # of reasons to agree: +6 # of reasons to disagree: -1 # of reasons to agree with reasons to agree: +0 # of reasons to agree with reason...
Read more

The Art Institute of Chicago is Better than the Denver Museum of Art

-
Image
Best reasons to agree : +1 The Art Institute of Chicago is bigger, and bigger museums are better. the second largest art museum in the United States, after the Metropolitan Museum of Art. The Art Institute of Chicago has over 260,000 works of art. You run out of things to see when going to the Denver art museum, because it doesn't change very often. Best reasons to disagree : -1 Its less expensive to stay and park in Denver, in 2012 parking was $28 in Chicago and $4 in Denver.  Images that agree : Coffin and Mummy of Paankhenamun, Third Intermediate Period, Dynasty 22 (c. 945–715 B.C.) Cartonnage, gold leaf, pigment; human remains Ancient Egyptian beliefs in the afterlife gave rise to the complex art and science of mummification. This vividly painted Mummy Case was the innermost of a series of shells that housed the body of a deceased person. The hieroglyphic inscriptions and painted scenes identify this mummy as Paankhenamun, a doorkeeper in th...
Read more